Skip directly to content

'Detroit Disassembled'

  • Mr. Bart's picture
    'Detroit Disassembled'
    Bart says (20 Jun '12)

    http://www.mlive.com/entertainment/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2012/06/photos_the_motor_city_doesnt_w.html#incart_river_default

    'Detroit Disassembled': Startling photos of the Motor City at the Grand Rapids Art Museum

    Published: Wednesday, June 20, 2012

    By Jeffrey Kaczmarczyk | jkaczmarczyk@mlive.com The Grand Rapids Press

    "National Time clock, former Cass Technical High School building," illustrates what has become of a once occupied building, now abandoned, in Detroit.

    Detroit Disassembled gallery (3 photos)

    GRAND RAPIDS, MI – Diana Ross, Lily Tomlin and Jack White of White Stripes went to school at Cass Tech in Detroit.

    Henry Ford, in his office in Highland Park, made decisions that would change forever how Americans would travel from place to place.

    Both buildings today are urban and industrial ruins.

    Photographer Andrew Moore captured the decline of such iconic buildings as in an exhibition titled “Detroit Disassembled: Photographs by Andrew Moore.”

    The 30 images, now on display at the Grand Rapids Art Museum, are startling.

    “I hope it’s not too disturbing. That wasn’t my purpose,” Moore said. “For better or worse, it’s something that we shouldn’t look away from.”

    “Detroit Disassembled” is on display as part of the museum’s summer-long “Cities in Transition” exhibition.

    Moore will be in town Thursday at the Grand Rapids Art Museum to discuss the transformation of Detroit and sign copies of his book, "Detroit Disassembled."

    No American city has seen more transition than the Motor City.

    Once the “Arsenal of Democracy,” Detroit’s population has fallen in half, and vast expanses of urban prairie.

    Alone among the great American cities, Detroit was a one-industry town that rose spectacularly and declined just as quickly.

    “It’s a city that grew up very quickly,” he said. “So it’s not surprising it declined so quickly.
    Detroit’s Michigan Central Station, designed by the architects who designed New York City’s Grand Central Terminal, opened in 1913 and was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1975.

    In 1988, the last train left the station. Today, the abandoned building spanning 14 acres is occupied by the homeless, and its dilapidated grandeur has appeared in films such as “8 Mile” starring Detroit’s own Eminem.

    “I didn’t want to photograph buildings,” Moore said. “The stories that the buildings told were compelling.”

    Moore spent 3-4 months over two years in 2008 and 2009 photographing the urban landscape.

    Friends got him into places such as Ford Motor’s Rouge River Plant and Highland Park Plant.

    “Those places are just incredible monuments to American history,” he said.

    In Henry Ford’s office, the original wool carpet had just been left there, and it decayed into organic material. It’s an astonishing site.”

    But looking for ruins wasn’t his objective.

    “I was looking for metaphors that were lyrical and poetic,” he said. “And not just the decline of a city.”

    Cass Technical High School, once a school for exceptional students in the Detroit Public Schools, was one of a number of schools closed and abandoned as it was.

    “In many cases they would just leave the schools. They wouldn’t take out the desks or the art supplies or even the computers,” he said. “It was just stupefying and horrifying to see that. In other places like Cuba I’ve been in, that would never happen. Nothing is wasted, everything is repurposed.”

    But in many places, nature has slowly reclaimed the man-made structures. In the Detroit Public School Depository, the skylight collapsed, and trees began growing, taking root in abandoned books, four floors above ground.

    “Instead of making books out of trees, trees were growing out of rotting books,” he said. “It’s beautiful and horrifying at the same time. To an artist, that kind of contradiction is a very rich and emotional story.”

    “Detroit Disassembled” first was shown at the Akron Art Museum in Akron, Ohio, another industrial city in transition, which saw the show as a cautionary tale.

    “That’s absolutely how they took it – what Akron could have been or what it could have been,” he said.

    The show also has been seen in Queens Museum of Art in New York City and now in Grand Rapids. Moore doubts it'll ever be seen in Detroit.

    “I think Detroit is treating the whole subject of its physical decline of its city much more gingerly,” he said. “It’s hard to confront the topic directly.”

    ”Cities in Transition”
    When : Now through Aug. 26
    Where: Grand Rapids Art Museum, 101 Monroe Center
    Hours: 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Tues.-Thurs., 10 a.m. - 9 p.m. Fri., 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Sat., noon-5 p.m. Sun. Closed Mondays.
    Call: GRAM at 616-831-1000

    ”Making History: An Evening with Andrew Moore”
    When: 7 p.m. Thursday (Doors open at 6 p.m., book signing at 6:30 p.m.)
    Where: Grand Rapids Art Museum, 101 Monroe Center
    Admission: $5; Free to museum members.
    Call: GRAM at 616-831-1000

    E-mail Jeffrey Kaczmarczyk: jkaczmarczyk@mlive.com
    Subscribe to his Facebook page or follow him on Twitter @ArtsWriter

    9
    Filed Under: Detroit Rock City
Mr. Bart's picture
on Wed, 06/20/2012 - 10:21am

http://www.mlive.com/entertainment/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2012/06/photos_the_motor_city_doesnt_w.html#incart_river_default

'Detroit Disassembled': Startling photos of the Motor City at the Grand Rapids Art Museum

Published: Wednesday, June 20, 2012

By Jeffrey Kaczmarczyk | jkaczmarczyk@mlive.com The Grand Rapids Press

"National Time clock, former Cass Technical High School building," illustrates what has become of a once occupied building, now abandoned, in Detroit.

Detroit Disassembled gallery (3 photos)

GRAND RAPIDS, MI – Diana Ross, Lily Tomlin and Jack White of White Stripes went to school at Cass Tech in Detroit.

Henry Ford, in his office in Highland Park, made decisions that would change forever how Americans would travel from place to place.

Both buildings today are urban and industrial ruins.

Photographer Andrew Moore captured the decline of such iconic buildings as in an exhibition titled “Detroit Disassembled: Photographs by Andrew Moore.”

The 30 images, now on display at the Grand Rapids Art Museum, are startling.

“I hope it’s not too disturbing. That wasn’t my purpose,” Moore said. “For better or worse, it’s something that we shouldn’t look away from.”

“Detroit Disassembled” is on display as part of the museum’s summer-long “Cities in Transition” exhibition.

Moore will be in town Thursday at the Grand Rapids Art Museum to discuss the transformation of Detroit and sign copies of his book, "Detroit Disassembled."

No American city has seen more transition than the Motor City.

Once the “Arsenal of Democracy,” Detroit’s population has fallen in half, and vast expanses of urban prairie.

Alone among the great American cities, Detroit was a one-industry town that rose spectacularly and declined just as quickly.

“It’s a city that grew up very quickly,” he said. “So it’s not surprising it declined so quickly.
Detroit’s Michigan Central Station, designed by the architects who designed New York City’s Grand Central Terminal, opened in 1913 and was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1975.

In 1988, the last train left the station. Today, the abandoned building spanning 14 acres is occupied by the homeless, and its dilapidated grandeur has appeared in films such as “8 Mile” starring Detroit’s own Eminem.

“I didn’t want to photograph buildings,” Moore said. “The stories that the buildings told were compelling.”

Moore spent 3-4 months over two years in 2008 and 2009 photographing the urban landscape.

Friends got him into places such as Ford Motor’s Rouge River Plant and Highland Park Plant.

“Those places are just incredible monuments to American history,” he said.

In Henry Ford’s office, the original wool carpet had just been left there, and it decayed into organic material. It’s an astonishing site.”

But looking for ruins wasn’t his objective.

“I was looking for metaphors that were lyrical and poetic,” he said. “And not just the decline of a city.”

Cass Technical High School, once a school for exceptional students in the Detroit Public Schools, was one of a number of schools closed and abandoned as it was.

“In many cases they would just leave the schools. They wouldn’t take out the desks or the art supplies or even the computers,” he said. “It was just stupefying and horrifying to see that. In other places like Cuba I’ve been in, that would never happen. Nothing is wasted, everything is repurposed.”

But in many places, nature has slowly reclaimed the man-made structures. In the Detroit Public School Depository, the skylight collapsed, and trees began growing, taking root in abandoned books, four floors above ground.

“Instead of making books out of trees, trees were growing out of rotting books,” he said. “It’s beautiful and horrifying at the same time. To an artist, that kind of contradiction is a very rich and emotional story.”

“Detroit Disassembled” first was shown at the Akron Art Museum in Akron, Ohio, another industrial city in transition, which saw the show as a cautionary tale.

“That’s absolutely how they took it – what Akron could have been or what it could have been,” he said.

The show also has been seen in Queens Museum of Art in New York City and now in Grand Rapids. Moore doubts it'll ever be seen in Detroit.

“I think Detroit is treating the whole subject of its physical decline of its city much more gingerly,” he said. “It’s hard to confront the topic directly.”

”Cities in Transition”
When : Now through Aug. 26
Where: Grand Rapids Art Museum, 101 Monroe Center
Hours: 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Tues.-Thurs., 10 a.m. - 9 p.m. Fri., 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Sat., noon-5 p.m. Sun. Closed Mondays.
Call: GRAM at 616-831-1000

”Making History: An Evening with Andrew Moore”
When: 7 p.m. Thursday (Doors open at 6 p.m., book signing at 6:30 p.m.)
Where: Grand Rapids Art Museum, 101 Monroe Center
Admission: $5; Free to museum members.
Call: GRAM at 616-831-1000

E-mail Jeffrey Kaczmarczyk: jkaczmarczyk@mlive.com
Subscribe to his Facebook page or follow him on Twitter @ArtsWriter

Forum category: 
KRSVal's picture

Oh hell no, Bart..I didn't think you were being negative at all...
I'll give you a shout at EKR if we head your way..you are so lucky to have so many good restaurants and drinking establishments in your area..
There are so many interesting details and stories about Detroit...my Ford dealer was telling me the other day that he remembered how when the auto crunch happened again around 2000, that Chrysler kept pumping out production event tho the sales weren't there..soon they had acres and acres of Chryslers parked an inch apart in empty fields around Detroit..
On the night before the cruise, I was driving to Metro airport in the dark-no streetlights on--the cities can't afford to replace the broken ones..
When we were downtown for the DSO show, the city looks better than I had seen it in awhile-the people and business are truly trying to revitalize. But even then, as KR's show was the only thing happening that night, the city was pretty empty. I compared it in my head to what Philly looks like that time of night--lots of ppl milling around.
My hubby recently stayed at the MGM Grand casino , and said the place was hopping during the week. Hopefully Our New President will help us get going again (lol!!)

Mr. Bart's picture

Val - I know there are a lot of positive things going on in the city of Detroit right now. I hope it continues. I have watched as many of those documentaries as I can. I think Dave Bing was a great choice as a leader of the city. He doesn't need it for his own personal agenda - he is doing it to pull that great city back up again.

I posted this article because I know people are always interested in the city of Detroit because of Kid. I also figured those in the metro Detroit area probably won't see the article because it was in the GR section of Mlive.

I would love to see that great city come back to life. Sorry if you thought I was posting this to be negative toward Detroit - like I'm piling on with everyone else. My Grandfather worked in the city of Detroit for decades and he always talked about what a great city it was and how sad he was to see it decline. He worked down there in the 40's and 50's, so he saw it growing and prosper. My mom used to race cars on Woodward. She used to tell stories about beating the guy's off the line with my Grandma's '57 Chevy. Every time I go down there I think of how great it must have been. I hope it will be again some day.

Val - Let me know if you plan on coming out to see it and I'll join you.

KRSVal's picture

I'll have to make a trip to GR to see this, Bart...there have been several TV documentaries on Detroit recently...there is still a lot of good and positive direction, but so much waste that happened before..

rocksavedmysoul's picture

Who said it, "Waste not, want not?" Terrible management of the Detroit schools over the years, as well as the City of Detroit. There is absolutely no accountability.

Mr. Bart's picture

You're welcome.

It amazes me that they didn't do anything with the schools but lock the door. Why didn't they hold an auction? Some kind of money would be better than nothing. They probably still could still do it but it's probably unsafe now. Maybe that's part of the problem in that city. People aren't thinking about all of the options available to them.

There is an elementary school in the district that I grew up in that was abandoned for about 10 years. They now want to make it a community center. They have to spend about $300k to get all the mold out of it now.

bluesuedeshoe's picture

Ditto Angel, thanks Bart!

Angel aka KRA's picture

good article thanks for shareing

Beckxy's picture

"Interesting and sad all at the same time". Absolutely Bart. This is kinda crazy, but I remember in school, a long time ago, the first ever book report I did where we were able to go into the library and pick out our own topic of interest - it was a biography on Henry Ford. My second was on Lions... lol But, it's kinda crazy how life comes back around again. God Bless Detroit.. and lets all give 'HOPE' for life to come back around again to the city that has a community of hard-working hands & dreams.

Mr. Bart's picture

Interesting and sad all at the same time. If you click on the link, there are 3 pictures.

I will probably go to this sometime this summer. It's not far from my house.